To roo or not to roo…

…that is the question:
Whether ’tis Nobler in the mind to suffer
The Slings and Arrows of outrageous Flogging,
Or to take Arms against a Sea of mounting,
And by opposing strangle them: to die, to sleep.
To sleep, perchance to dream, to be awakened prematurely by crowing;
Ay, there’s the rub.

Oh, stop complaining. I could have taken that much further, trust me.

When we first decided to get chickens last spring, The Man had one firm caveat: no roosters. It seems one of our neighbours had had a rooster a few years back, pre me, and another neighbour, one right next to us, had kicked up such a fuss about the crowing that he threatened a civil lawsuit.

Now, we are zoned for chickens, including roosters. I’m not sure if he had a legal leg to stand on, but he was vocal enough and vociferous enough that The Man wanted none of it. Which was fine with me. I had no desire to be wakened at 5am, or flogged, or, if we’re being honest here, to eat chick zygote.

In the year that has passed, I have taught the basics of the birds and the bees to Stepdaughter the Elder, and she could not help but pass along the more lurid details to a horrified Stepdaughter the Younger, so I am no longer quite so concerned about explaining a rooster’s husbandly duties to them, but that was also a consideration at the time.

This all makes me seem quite the wuss to many of you chckeneers out there, I know, but there has been domestic tranquility to be found in being able to tell the girls, honestly, that no chick could ever, possibly, under any conditions, emerge from their breakfast.

Roosters certainly have their place on the farm. A good one will protect his ladies at the cost of his own life (as did our Jack in his new home), will find treats for them, will be gentle at mating, and will be patriarch to many (free) chicks.

A bad one will harass his hens mercilessly (no means no, dammit!), rip out their back feathers in so doing, and have a go at you and your children while he’s at it. There is many a rooster horror story to be found on Backyard Chickens, roosters who could only be approached with a broom or stick or by certain members of the family, roosters who flew up and left scars on faces, narrowly missing eyes, roosters who eventually earned their way into a cooking pot.

So, at 15 weeks of age, Jack went away, and, still very young, died defending his new ladies from a fox. Sniff. I have a feeling he could have been one of the good ones. And, guess what? It seems the local rooster-hater wasn’t the neighbour herself, but the boyfriend of the neightbour. The now-ex-boyfriend. Past tense.

The path is clear on that count. Knowing that, do I now want a rooster?

Not really. And, if I were to change my mind, it would be for a very well-bred gentleman of a cool breed. a true purebred Araucana (bearded and rumpless, laying true blue eggs…quite rare):

Or a British Blue Orpington (a glorious feathered basketball, right down to the feet:

It would not be a rooster of a mutt breed. Sorry. I’ll have plenty of boys next spring when the poults arrive, and one big, beautiful, well-conformed, well-behaved one will get to stay.

All of this to say…I think we have a roo. It was all there for me to see. I saw the pieces of the puzzle, but they didn’t fall together until Aoxa commented on this pic:

They have eyes but do not see…

Check out Audrey in the back right. Yes, one might miss the thicker legs (I did; Aoxa did not), but how could one miss that comb? That prominent, glowing, orange comb??!!

Ummmm…hello? Anyone home? Is this thing on?! Compare it to Ava’s, at left.

As soon as Aoxa cautioned me, all the little pieces fell into place: Audrey was the smallest of the three at first:

And now, is the largest and the most aggressive. Sigh. Audrey is Aubrey, I’m pretty sure. Chicken Debbie is dropping by this afternoon to put in her valuable two cents’ worth.

I considered keeping her/him. I’m still considering it. I could do worse than brooding Easter Eggers, and it would be very easy to tell which eggs to incubate (hint: the green ones). And Easter Egger chicks would be very easy to sell; Chicken Debbie has a day just for them every May.

The troublesome neighbour is gone, the girls know about the fundamentals of sex, and I’m up early anyway. So…why not keep him?

Okay, this is embarrassing. I still don’t want to t eat chick zygote. Sorry.

That being said, last night I was prepared to keep him if no viable, humane alternative presented itself. But one has.

When Chicken Debbie ordered this year’s batch of Easter Eggers, from which mine came, a man special ordered a roo, and his male chick died. Debbie will call him and ask if he’s interested. It seems to me that the odds are good.

The business of egg laying is brutally unkind to males. Except for a very few, they are unneeded, and their fates are generally unhappy. I spend a little more for sexed pullets, which spares me the unpleasant task of disposing of boys. But sexing chicks is more art than science, and an error ratio of 1:10 is considered predictable and acceptable. When I had a roo in twelve last year, I accepted it with good grace. But one in three?!

What can I say; it’s a gift.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “To roo or not to roo…

  1. He looks EXACTLY like my Stanley at a day old.. I knew at 2 weeks when he was the slowest feathering in that he was a boy. He is very well behaved and gorgeous. Easter Eggers sell very well no matter where you are. The boys are an array of colours, and can pass their egg coloured gene onto your older hens’ offspring.

    I have never had a mean roo, and I have six. As long as they know you are king, they respect you. One boy to 18 girls will not leave bald spots on your girls.

    Yes. Definitely a boy. I would be absolutely shocked if it was a girl.

    Here are comparisons of Stanley from day 1 to now (17 weeks this Saturday)


    Day 1


    1 week


    2 weeks


    3 weeks (one with least amount of feathers)


    5 weeks


    5 weeks


    8 weeks


    10 weeks


    12 weeks


    14 weeks


    16 weeks old

    He is very people friendly. Eating out of your hand. I saw him try to mate one of his older brood mates today for the first time. He’s also crowing – really good crow too!

    I think you should give a rooster a chance.

    Your last one was a production red rooster, which would have been harder to sell chicks of than EEs. Just a thought :P

  2. I totally shared your beliefs about roosters until I found a beautiful blue laced red wyandotte pair for sale, the owner would not sell the hen without the roo, so Wilson became my first boy. And he is SO awesome. I cannot imagine the flock without him. He’s gentle, monogamous (he only mates with Hen, the other BLRW) he makes sure all the girls get the good bugs, helps Hen survey all the possible nesting spots hour after hour day after day. He guards her while she lays. He’s gentle about mating. He also has a very quiet crow that makes him sound like he is saying, “I am Ludvig”.

    Then we got Claus, a bigger Sicilian Buttercup, much younger and full of spitfire. He has attacked my husband and I and he does pack a wallop. His crow is louder but I actually find I miss their crows if they don’t wake me up (as when I have the AC on in the bedroom). He is motivated to mate with any available female at any time ever but is still gentle about it. Basically, he’s like a 17 year old boy in all respects. But I don’t regret getting him. He’ll grow out of a lot of the annoying stuff and he is 100% pro at keeping the girls safe from airborne predators, something Wilson is only moderately interested in.

    My two roos coexist and while I sometimes threaten Claus with a less than pleasant fate, he’s one of us and he’s also exceptionally gorgeous. It’s fun to watch them all interact. I honestly feel like if you don’t have a roo at least once you’re missing out on an awesome part of chickeneering. I vote you give it a try. If you don’t like the roo you end up with you have options (including making a rooster bachelor pad which I intend to do as I feel sorry for all the loss of rooster life in the chicken industry).

    • Those little bantams are fire crackers! And all roosters go through a stage. They crow a lot, mate A LOT and declare themselves king with other roosters. I would never tolerate any rooster attacking a human though. Unless of course he is under 8 weeks old. Then he is really just a baby :P

      Some roosters are nicer than hens. I have a few just like that! The only issue I have with my Barred rock roo is he does not like my bantam silkie rooster, which I don;’t believe she really has to worry about that one!

      One rooster will love every hen. My roosters all take very good care of babies, and my silkie rooster is currently fathering 13 in the same little pen with the two moms. He feeds them keeps them warm. It’s incredibly endearing, and I could never imagine a flock without a rooster. They are majestic!

      Oh and they protect! That’s another bonus!

    • I agree we need to have a roo eventually, I’m just not sure I want it to be THIS roo. If I’m going to have a roo, I’d like him to be part of a proper breeding program. I also heard that mature roos can be really brutal to young jennies, and that’s a concern for next year. ACK!! One major adjustment at a time!!

      As I said, fate may intervene. If there isn’t an good, safe home for him, I will keep him. I won’t resign him to the stock pot.

      • Mature roos? I would have thought it would be the Juvenile roos that would be mean to the jennies – I know I caught my six month old roo trying to mate my goslings.. I grabbed him by the tail and removed him very roughly. He won’t do that again. Sang the egg song for a good 5 minutes lol.

        He’s one you have to watch. I’m not sure i want to keep him yet. He just mates the ducks.. If I’m going to keep him, he has to father some chicks.. I mean really..

        You could keep him for now. I think he’s beautiful <3

      • He is pretty, but he’s also flighty and a bit aggressive with the girls at the moment. Keeps jumping on their backs. Prodigious, isn’t he?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s